Florida time shares find law to bar resellers from transfer properties
11 views - published on April 30th, 2013 in Disney News tagged Disney, disney timeshares, timeshare, vacationLosing millions of dollars in delinquent upkeep fees, Florida’s time-share attention is lobbying state lawmakers to outlaw a argumentative resale plan of send badly devalued time shares into bombard companies famous as “Viking ships.”
Under a practice, owners unfortunate to be absolved of their time shares — and a requirement to compensate hundreds, or even thousands, of dollars in annual impost — compensate time-share “transfer companies” to take their units off their hands.
Those send companies, if they are incompetent to resell or lease a time shares, might pierce them into an differently asset-less corporate entity — referred to as a Viking boat — and stop profitable all dues, withdrawal a strange resorts with no choice though to foreclose and take behind a properties.
-
Get content alerts: Sign adult to accept Politics content alerts on your mobile phone
-
Photos: 100 years of U.S. presidential races
Justice System
Lobbying
Florida Legislature
The American Resort Development Association, a trade organisation that wants to anathema a practice, calls a sales reprobate and says they have led to during slightest $8 million in delinquent upkeep fees opposite a industry.
That’s a debt that eventually gets upheld on to remaining time-share owners, as resort-management associations make adult a disproportion by charging even aloft dues.
Viking ships are “a problem that has been plaguing time-share associations opposite a state of Florida,” pronounced Jason Gamel, a lobbyist for ARDA. “It’s not a association’s pursuit to bail out a send company.”
But people concerned in a resale business contend ARDA is exploiting a emanate to chuck adult a underbrush of new restrictions that will eventually make it harder for all time-share owners to resell their properties. The finish result, they say, will be to revoke secondary-market foe for developers who are offered new units — and to keep owners sealed into properties for that they can ceaselessly be squeezed for annual dues.
The normal time-share upkeep price in a U.S. is $786 per week of use, according to ARDA’s research. That means a singular section can beget some-more than $40,000 a year in fees.
“They’re perplexing to keep each time-share owners sealed into their time share so they can continue to expostulate them … for a annual assessment. Because that’s a income stream. That’s how they get paid,” pronounced William Stander, a lobbyist representing Timeshare Closing Services, an Orlando-based pretension group that handles time-share closings.
This attention food quarrel is contrast a strength of ARDA in a Republican-controlled Florida Legislature. The classification is led by some of a tourism industry’s biggest companies — including Disney, Marriott and Wyndham, among others — and by a domestic cabinet gave about $425,000 to state GOP during a 2012 elections, and $180,000 to a Florida Democratic Party.
Viking ships emerged in a time-share attention amid a tellurian mercantile downturn, as time shares plummeted in value and many owners motionless they wanted out.
Some time-share companies do small to assistance such buyers. In 2011, ARDA’s investigate arm surveyed time-share resorts tranquil by owners associations — generally comparison resorts, as opposite to newer ones tranquil by a developer still offered units — and found that usually 54 percent of those responding helped owners lease their units, while usually 28 percent had resale programs to assistance owners.
Into that opening stepped third-party companies that would assign often-steep fees to take a units from demure owners and then, if incompetent to resell them, dump a time shares into manikin corporations.
“The impact of those supposed service companies on a associations is unequivocally detrimental, since they don’t compensate their assessments, and they don’t caring if there’s actions taken opposite them,” pronounced Tom Durkee, an Orlando accountant who represented one time-share plan in that scarcely 10 percent of a units were owned by such entities.
Among many other provisions, a legislation ARDA is now pulling in Tallahassee (HB 7025) would make it bootleg for people to attend in a send when they know a chairman or entity appropriation a time share does not have a “ability, means or intent” to compensate all assessments compared with a time share. Violators could be strike with a excellent of as many as $10,000 — and a polite lawsuit in that a government organisation for a time-share review could redeem any delinquent upkeep fees.
But critics contend a legislation’s denunciation is too deceptive and would display people and companies concerned in resales to so many guilt that they would exclude to get concerned during all.
The legislation “makes any chairman — possibly a seller or my client, a pretension representative who’s a celebration to a transaction — probable if a subsequent owners doesn’t compensate a assessments,” Stander said. “We consider it’s eventually going to solidify adult a delegate market.”
Asked either Timeshare Closing Services has been concerned in sales to Viking ships, Stander pronounced usually that a organisation has stopped doing business with resale companies whenever it has schooled that they are intent in a practice.
Opponents contend time-share developers and owners associations already have a pill when owners stop profitable dues: They can foreclose on a properties and afterwards resell themselves. ARDA successfully lobbied Florida lawmakers in 2010 to emanate faster and cheaper “nonjudicial” foreclosure routine for time shares.
ARDA’s Gamel pronounced foreclosure is no solution, however. For one, he said, even nonjudicial foreclosures can take months and cost thousands of dollars. And for another, many of a resorts many expected to be harm by Viking ships are comparison and no longer intent in active sales, so they can't simply resell units themselves.
jrgarcia@orlandosentinel.com or 407-420-5414. skclarke@orlandosentinel.com or 407-420-5664.